ADHD: A Hidden Strength?
Greenvale Park Elementary Principal David Craft shares his thoughts.
One of the most rewarding aspects of my job is talking to a parent about his/her child. These conversations are insightful and the topics vary. I learn a lot about individual children with respect to developing quality educational programming. One of the most recurring topics is the diagnosis of ADHD.
There is a lot known about ADHD and there are many misconceptions. For instance, did you know that the most frequently diagnosed demographic is Caucasian, middle-class boys? ADHD is the most commonly studied and diagnosed psychiatric disorder and is typically considered a deficit.
Or is it? Consider this illustration: There are farmers and hunters.
A farmer has the job of going out into the fields and grooming the land into long rows for planting. In the past, a farmer would sow seeds one or two at a time, tediously moving ahead in a predictable fashion for hours on end.
A hunter might be standing around a campfire listening to a story when from out of the corner of his eye he sees a leaf falling in the woods. It catches his attention and he turns back to the conversation. Then, a moment later, he hears a twig snap. He grabs his bow and arrow and turns back to the conversation until he hears footfalls in the woods. In the blink of an eye he bounds into the woods.
I believe we would all agree that farming is a skillset and that hunting is a skillset. Therefore, they both have value. In this illustration, the hunter is obviously the skillset of a child with ADHD.
Schools, however, typically function in the ways of the farmer skill set. Assessment usually involves a child’s ability to repeat small details in order to accomplish a bigger task. For a child with a hunter skillset, this is the most difficult way of learning. Sadly, the ability to express a powerful imagination, searching insight and unusual intuition is not highly prized in a typical classroom setting, according to Lara Honos-Webb.
Over the course of my career I have found that parents lament about ADHD. Most educational discussions regarding an ADHD child’s educational programming focus on turning the hunter into a farmer. Indeed, when hunters find themselves growing up on a farm, not farming is a bad idea. However, not hunting is also a bad idea.
Todd Mulliken, a Twin Cities family therapist, talks about it this way. The best strategy for helping (any child really) is to give them as many opportunities as is possible to travel in lanes of traffic that define their particular skillset.
“We need to define our children by what we are for; not by what we are against," he says.
There are some obvious “lanes of traffic” in the case of an ADHD child. Honos-Webb, in 2005, wrote an insightful article about the gift of ADHD. It deals with transforming a child's problems into strengths. I believe the “strengths” are the lanes of traffic in which an ADHD child should be traveling. For the purpose of addressing what is an obviously pervasive concern for families and schools, I will address these strengths, or gifts, as a series of Gazette articles to finish out the school year. Consider this strength until next time.
Seeing the Big Picture:
Children with ADHD are excellent at getting the big picture, in and out of the classroom. Students with ADHD may miss the little details, but they are masters at understanding the importance and meaning of material. For example, children with ADHD may be struck with wonder and awe at the miraculous workings of nature as they learn about photosynthesis and how plants take in sunlight to grow. They may wonder what happens in cloud-covered regions of the world and start to generate ideas for how to get sunlight to plants on cloudy days. As this example illustrates, children with ADHD are often deeply engaged in material in creative and novel ways. They may not remember any of the details about the roles of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the process of photosynthesis, but they are very curious and interested and typically try to create solutions to problems in creative ways.
There are few courses of study in the educational system that reward the startling gifts an ADHD child has to offer. The good news is that if your child can emerge unscathed from his education, he can find his niche in the real world that will reward him highly for his ardent curiosity, creativity, and ability to solve problems in innovative ways.
Lara Honos-Webb
kirk horton
10:04 am on Monday, April 4, 2011
As a former elementary school principal myself, I am quite aware that attention difficulties are just the tip of the iceberg. ADHD children can't filter out distractions, finish tasks on-time, use their memory optimally, etc. A pill doesn't teach these skills. The author is correct, our schools are not structured to accommodate the needs of these children.
My wife and I opted to use cognitive training for our son, Alex, who was diagnosed with ADHD. We used Play Attention (www.playattention.com) and ADHD Nanny (www.adhdnanny.com). We've been very successful with these approaches. I was so successful with Alex, that I brought Play Attention to our school. Big success there as well.
It's just important to know that medicine teaches nothing. Parents and teachers must actively participate to help change a child's life. With some understanding and simple accommodations, we can make significant changes.
Betsy Gasior
2:24 pm on Monday, April 4, 2011
However, medication must be acknowledged as the tool it can be for many children. Our son, diagnosed at the age of 5 after a year of intensive study after study both medical and behavioral to rule out any other diagnosis (now 15 and an Eagle Scout) would not be where he is today if it weren't for the combination of behavior modification therapy and his medication. The pill is what helps his brain to focus enough to absorb the teaching. Without it, no amount of behavior modification or teaching approaches is enough.
I liken the use of medication to the use of eyeglasses. Just as a nearsighted or farsighted person needs eyeglasses to sharpen their focus (I can fumble around the house without my glasses, but could never cook, clean, work, drive etc without them), so do some children with ADD/ADHD need their medication to help their brains to focus. Teachers, doctors and other parents that scoff at the use of medications are insulting to those children and their parents that had to make a heartbreaking decision.
Lastly, our son is a very creative person with his music and his drawing. We fully believe that he would not be as tapped into his creative side without ADHD. We feel it opens up a whole new way of seeing the world for him, and how he expresses himself.
Alicia R. Ruelaz, M.D.
4:56 pm on Monday, April 4, 2011
I agree. Medication is helpful when used as a tool but there are many aspects of ADHD that require additional approaches. After struggling with ADHD myself and then becoming a psychiatrist treating others with this condition, I know that it's important to understand what is going on in the brain, what medications can and can't do and the psychological and behavioral approaches available. Though geared towards adults, the book "Is It ADHD or My iPhone?", gives this understanding and assisstance